Reviewers describe Antigua Brewing Company as a strong choice for craft beer, with a wide selection of styles inspired by beers from around the world. Guests mention enjoying the variety, with one reviewer singling out a German-style beer as a favorite. Food also receives notable praise, including tacos that one visitor called their favorite meal of the trip, along with a hot chicken sandwich and ceviche.

The rooftop is one of the biggest draws, with frequent mentions of sweeping volcano views, sunsets, and plenty of seating. Reviewers also note the lively atmosphere, good music, happy hour, and a stage used for entertainment and sporting events. The terrace can become crowded, so the quality of the view may depend on where guests are seated, and one visitor felt the music was too loud for a relaxed afternoon.

Service is generally described positively, with several reviewers mentioning friendly staff and good experiences, including a large private rooftop event that was handled smoothly. One guest, however, reported very slow service and said their server forgot about them for around 20 minutes. Overall, the reviews portray Antigua Brewing Company as a popular rooftop brewery known for craft beer, satisfying food, volcano views, and an energetic social atmosphere.