Reviewers describe Piccadilly as a versatile restaurant serving breakfast, Italian, and American-style dishes at reasonable prices. Specific favorites include chilaquiles, traditional Guatemalan breakfast, pizza, pasta, garlic bread with cheese, and drinks such as horchata and peach tea. Breakfast guests also mention that juice and coffee are included with some meals, with the coffee receiving particularly strong praise.

The restaurant is described as spacious, calm, and pleasantly decorated, with a convenient location about two blocks from Antigua’s Central Park. Reviewers generally feel the portions and food quality offer good value, and several mention that the atmosphere works well for breakfast, lunch, or dinner.

Service is mostly described as friendly, attentive, and quick, although a few guests report inconsistent customer service. Overall, the reviews portray Piccadilly as an affordable, centrally located restaurant with good pizza and pasta, satisfying breakfasts, varied drinks, and a relaxed dining environment.